What your NBN bill actually pays for, line by line

Photo: rawpixel via rawpixel (CC0 1.0)
Eighty-nine dollars a month. That’s what a friend in Coburg is paying for a 100 Mbps plan, and last week she asked me the question I’ve been asked in one form or another for fifteen years: where does the money go? Not in the vague sense. In the sense of which company gets which slice, and why the $59 plans she remembers from 2016 are gone.
The honest answer is that an NBN bill is three things stacked on top of each other. A wholesale charge set by NBN Co and policed by the ACCC. A retailer’s margin, which covers everything from the modem in your hallway to the call centre in Manila. And a decade of policy decisions that decided what the first number would be. I’ll take them in that order, because that’s the order the money flows.
The wholesale layer: what NBN Co charges your retailer #
NBN Co doesn’t sell to you. It sells to retail service providers, the Telstras and Aussie Broadbands and Superloops, under a contract called the Wholesale Broadband Agreement. The prices in that agreement are constrained by a regulatory instrument called the Special Access Undertaking, which the ACCC accepted in its current varied form in October 2023 after a negotiation that ran for the better part of three years. If you want the current price list, NBN Co publishes it on its own site, and I’d encourage anyone who pays a bill to read it once. It is shorter than you’d think.
For most of the network’s life the wholesale charge had two parts, and this is the bit that explains the vanished cheap plans. There was a per-connection charge for the speed tier (the industry called it AVC) and a separate charge for capacity, the CVC, which retailers bought in bulk and shared across their customers. If your retailer under-bought capacity, everyone slowed down at 8pm. If it over-bought, its margin evaporated. Retailers hated it. The ACCC’s Wholesale Market Indicators reports from those years show the CVC squeeze in numbers, quarter after quarter.
The 2023 undertaking started retiring the CVC charge, beginning with the faster tiers. That’s the single biggest structural change in NBN pricing since the network launched, and it’s why a 100 Mbps plan today is a cleaner product than the same plan in 2019. The retailer knows what it costs. It didn’t always.

Why the $59 plan disappeared #
Two reasons, and neither of them is a conspiracy.
The first is that the cheapest tiers were priced at the wholesale level to be unattractive. A 12 Mbps service cost NBN Co roughly the same to deliver as a 50 Mbps service, so pricing it much lower made no commercial sense to a company with a very large debt to service. Retailers responded by steering customers to 50 Mbps, which the ACCC’s speed-tier data shows became the default plan in the country within about two years of that pricing decision.
The second reason is that in September 2025 NBN Co lifted the speeds attached to its faster tiers under what it called the Accelerate Great programme, so that the tier a retailer had been selling as 100/20 became a 500/50 product on fibre and HFC. When the tier above you gets five times faster for a similar wholesale price, the retailer has every incentive to move you up. That’s fine if you want it. Plenty of households don’t, and I’d argue the industry has been a bit too keen to pretend they do.
The retail layer: what your provider keeps #
Take the wholesale charge off the top of your bill and what’s left is the retailer’s gross margin. On a mid-range plan that’s typically somewhere in the twenty to thirty dollar range, though it varies a lot by retailer and the figure moves every time NBN Co adjusts its price list. Out of that margin the retailer pays for backhaul from the NBN’s 121 points of interconnect to its own network, for its transit to the wider internet, for the modem it sent you, for billing, for support, for marketing, and for the customer acquisition cost that its finance team is quietly amortising over the eighteen months it expects you to stay.
This is where the difference between providers actually lives. Two retailers buying the exact same wholesale product can deliver very different experiences depending on how much capacity they provision between the point of interconnect and the internet. The Telecommunications Consumer Protections Code sets the floor on things like billing and complaint handling, and the ACCC’s broadband performance monitoring programme measures who is actually delivering the speed they sell. I read the quarterly report every time it comes out. Most people never will, which is a shame, because it’s the closest thing to a scoreboard the industry has.
The history layer: why the first number is what it is #
NBN Co was built with government equity and government-guaranteed debt, and for most of its life it was expected to earn a commercial return on both. That expectation set the wholesale price. Every argument about whether the NBN is too expensive is really an argument about whether that return was ever realistic, and the 2023 undertaking was, in part, the moment the company and the regulator agreed it wasn’t.
I’ve sat in enough Senate Estimates sessions to know that this is the part of the conversation where people start shouting about fibre versus copper. It matters, but it’s a separate argument. The technology in the street affects what speed you can buy. The financing model affected what it cost. Both are still with us.
The three things that aren’t on the bill #
There are costs in the system that never appear on a residential invoice, and they explain a fair bit of the pricing behaviour above.
The first is the Regional Broadband Scheme. Since 2021 every fixed-line connection in the country, NBN or not, has carried a monthly levy that funds the fixed wireless and satellite networks in the bush. It’s a few dollars a month, it’s collected at the wholesale level, and your retailer builds it into the plan price rather than itemising it. The ACMA administers it and publishes the rate. I don’t have a problem with the scheme, for the record; a national network that only paid for itself in Sydney and Melbourne wouldn’t be much of a national network. But it’s one reason the floor on a city plan is higher than the underlying cost of the city connection.
The second is the cost of the migration off the old copper. Telstra was paid, over many years, for the progressive disconnection of its network and for access to its ducts and pits. That money was borrowed by NBN Co and sits in the debt the wholesale price has to service. Nobody on a residential plan ever sees a line item for it. Everyone pays it.
The third is churn. The retail broadband market has one of the highest customer-switching rates of any subscription business in the country, and the acquisition cost of a new customer (the discounted first six months, the free modem, the cashback through a comparison site) is recovered from the customers who stay. If you’ve been on the same plan with the same retailer for four years and never rung to ask for a better rate, you are, with respect, subsidising the people who did. The remedy is a phone call, and the TCP Code obliges the retailer to tell you about the plans it currently sells.
What the regulator can and can’t do #
People write to me expecting the ACCC to set retail prices. It doesn’t, and it can’t. Its lever is the wholesale layer, through the undertaking, and its megaphone is the data it publishes: the Wholesale Market Indicators reports on what retailers are buying, and the Measuring Broadband Australia programme on what they’re delivering. The second is the one worth bookmarking. It’s funded by the government, run by an independent measurement firm using boxes in real homes, and it names the retailers that consistently deliver their advertised evening speeds and the ones that don’t. Nothing a retailer says in an advertisement carries as much weight as its line in that table.
What the ACCC also does, and this gets less attention, is hold NBN Co to a set of service standards under the same undertaking: fault rectification times, connection windows, rebates when they’re missed. Those rebates flow to the retailer, not to you, and whether the retailer passes them on is, again, a retailer decision. Ask.
Reading your own bill #
If you want to do the exercise yourself, it’s a ten-minute job. Find your speed tier on the bill. Find that tier on NBN Co’s published wholesale price list. Subtract. What’s left is what your retailer is keeping, and the interesting question is whether it’s earning it. A provider charging a wider margin but provisioning generously and answering the phone in four minutes might be worth it. One charging the same margin and congesting at night is not, and the ACCC’s performance data will usually tell you which is which before your own experience does.
My friend in Coburg, for what its worth, is on a retailer that sits in the top third of that report. I told her to stop worrying about the eighty-nine dollars and start worrying about whether she’s on the right tier. She’s paying for 100 Mbps and using, on a good day, about nine. Which is a different article, and probably the the next one I’ll write.
— Marcus Tully, Editor, Technology Spectator