Mobiles & Mobility

How to buy a phone in Australia without paying for what you won’t use

How to buy a phone in Australia without paying for what you won't use

7 min read·1526 words·Updated 22 September 2026

Twenty-two years of reading carrier results, ACCC reports and the occasional leaked retail incentive scheme has left me with one firm view about how Australians buy phones: the industry is organised to sell you the wrong one. Not a bad one. The wrong one, on the wrong terms, for reasons that have everything to do with the carrier’s plan margin and nothing to do with what you’ll use. The people I know who are happiest with their phones bought on four things, battery, screen, camera and price, and ignored everything else. This is the guide I’d write for them, and it’s the one the retail channel’s commission structure will never let a shop assistant give you.

Outright or on a plan #

The carriers sell phones on 24 or 36-month repayment plans bundled with a SIM plan, and the pitch is that it’s interest-free. It is. The catch is that you’re tied to that carrier’s plan pricing for the term, the plan is rarely the cheapest available, and if you leave early the remaining handset balance is due at once. Over three years the plan premium usually costs more than the phone would have on a credit card.

Buying outright, from the manufacturer, a retailer or a carrier’s outright price, and pairing it with a SIM-only plan from whoever’s cheapest, wins on cost for almost everyone who can manage the upfront amount. The SIM-only market has dozens of resellers on the three networks, the ones the industry calls MVNOs, and the ACCC’s telecommunications reports track how much cheaper they run. Switching between them takes an afternoon and keeps your number.

iPhone gold charging cable plugged — buy a phone Australia
Photo: Rawpixel via Rawpixel (CC0 1.0)

The four things that actually matter #

Battery. Look for the milliamp-hour figure and then ignore the manufacturer’s “all-day” claim, because everyone claims all day. A phone with a 5,000 mAh battery and an efficient chip will comfortably do a long day with heavy use. Below 4,000 you’re charging at lunch within a year, since batteries lose capacity, and the phone that lasted a day new lasts an afternoon at month 18.

Screen. Size is preference; brightness isn’t. Australian sun is brutal and a screen rated below about 800 nits peak is hard to read outdoors, which matters if you use maps on a worksite or read on a train platform. Refresh rate, the 90 or 120 Hz figure, makes scrolling smoother and costs battery, and most people can’t tell the difference after a week.

Camera. The main sensor on any phone above the budget tier is good enough for anything that isn’t printed larger than a magazine page. The differences reviewers care about are in low light, zoom and video, and the honest question is whether you shoot those things. If your photos are of kids, food and receipts, the mid-range camera is fine. If you shoot the footy under lights, it’s not, and that’s where the money goes.

Price, which is the one people apologise for. Don’t. The $500 to $800 tier of the market has, for about five years now, delivered phones that do 95 per cent of what the $2,000 tier does. The last five per cent is real and it’s also the part most people never use.

Storage is the last quiet upsell. The base model has become genuinely adequate for most people since photos moved to the cloud, and the step up to the next tier is priced at several times what the memory costs the manufacturer. Check how much of your current phone’s storage is actually used before you pay for double.

Bands, 5G and the thing nobody checks #

A phone bought in Australia from a carrier or a big retailer will work on the Australian networks. A phone bought from an overseas online marketplace may not, and this is the single most common cause of the “why is my signal terrible” letter I get. The bands to check are 5G n78, which is the main capacity band in cities, and n28 and 4G band 28, the 700 MHz band that carries coverage in regional areas and into buildings. A phone that lacks band 28 will show full bars on the main street and nothing in the back of the shopping centre. Since the 3G shutdown the phone also has to support VoLTE emergency calling here, and imports often don’t. Ask, in writing, before you buy an import.

5G itself: nice to have, not essential. Coverage is good in the cities and thin outside them, and for most people the practical difference from a good 4G connection is small. Every current phone above the bottom tier has it, so it’s not usually a decision, but don’t pay extra for it on a budget handset.

Buying a phone in Australia: the checks that matter. In roughly the order they save you money
Diagram: Technology Spectator

Refurbished, and what “refurbished” means #

A refurbished phone from the manufacturer’s own programme or a reputable refurbisher is a genuinely good buy, particularly for the expensive brands. It’s been tested, usually has a new battery, and comes with a warranty. A “refurbished” phone from a marketplace listing with no warranty and a stock photo is a used phone with a marketing word attached. The difference is the warranty and the battery health figure, and a seller who won’t show you the battery health is telling you what it is.

Your rights, which are better than the store will say #

Under the Australian Consumer Law, a phone comes with guarantees that it’s of acceptable quality and will last a reasonable time, and “reasonable” for a $1,500 phone is a lot longer than the manufacturer’s one-year warranty. If it fails at eighteen months with a fault that isn’t your doing, you’re entitled to a repair, replacement or refund from the retailer, and the retailer cannot send you to the manufacturer to sort it out, however much they’d prefer to. The consumer law guidance sets this out and the ACCC has taken retailers to court over exactly this. I’ve stood in stores and listened to staff tell customers the opposite. Some didn’t know. Some, according to the internal training material that occasionally reaches my inbox, did.

Extended warranties sold at the counter mostly duplicate rights you already have. Screen insurance is a different product and can be worth it if you’re clumsy or work on a site, but read the excess. Some of them cost more per claim than a screen repair at an independent shop.

The plan behind the phone #

The phone is a one-off cost; the plan is the thing you pay for 36 months, and it’s where the carriers make their margin. The ACCC’s Communications Market Report, which comes out every year and which I read the day it lands, has tracked for a decade the gap between what the three network owners charge on their own brands and what the resellers on the same networks charge. The gap is large and it has not closed. A reseller on the Telstra wholesale network is not on the whole Telstra network, and that’s the honest caveat; the wholesale footprint excludes some regional coverage. For anyone in a city, the difference is invisible. For anyone on a farm, ask the reseller for the coverage map, not the carrier’s.

Data allowances have inflated to the point where most plans include more than most people use, so the sensible comparison is price per month for the amount you actually consumed last quarter, which your current app will tell you. International roaming, if you travel, is the other line worth reading, because the difference between a carrier’s daily roaming pass and a travel eSIM bought before you leave is often the price of a decent dinner every day of the trip.

Trade-ins and the resale question #

The carriers and manufacturers have leaned hard into trade-in offers, and the arithmetic is worth doing rather than assuming. A trade-in value quoted at the counter is usually below what the same phone fetches on the second-hand market, sometimes by a wide margin, and it’s often conditional on buying the new phone through a plan. If you have the patience to wipe the old phone properly and sell it yourself, you’ll generally do better. If you don’t, the manufacturer’s own trade-in programme is usually fairer than the carrier’s. Either way, do a full reset and remove the phone from your accounts before it leaves your hands; the ACCC’s scam data has a category for exactly what happens when people don’t.

What I’d buy #

Opinion, then. The sensible purchase for most Australians is a mid-range phone from a major brand, bought outright, on a cheap SIM-only plan, kept for four years with a battery replacement at year three. That’s not the purchase the industry is built to sell you, because the industry is built on two-year upgrade cycles and plan bundles, and every carrier result I’ve read since 2004 has a line in it that depends on you not working this out.

The phone in my pocket cost $649 and is three years old, and the only reason I’d replace it is that the battery has started to behave like one of my valve radios: fine for an hour, then a slow fade. Everyday it does everything I need. I don’t reckon the $2,000 one would, and I’ve been lent most of them.

— Marcus Tully, Editor, Technology Spectator

Back to top button