Life after the 3G shutdown: coverage, triple zero and dead devices

Photo: rawpixel via rawpixel (CC0 1.0)
The last letter I answered before the switch-off was from a reader in his seventies with a flip phone he’d had since 2014, asking which of the three carriers would keep it working. None of them would, and I had to write back and say so. That was 2023. The 3G networks are gone now: TPG’s Vodafone network switched its off in January 2024, and Telstra and Optus both closed theirs at the end of October 2024 after a delay and a Senate inquiry. Nearly two years on, I still get letters most weeks from people who’ve discovered something in their life depended on it. This is what actually changed, and what’s still catching people.
What the shutdown was for #
Spectrum. The radio frequencies the 3G networks used, particularly the 850 and 900 MHz bands that travel a long way and get into buildings, are worth far more carrying 4G and 5G traffic than carrying a fading number of 3G calls. Telstra’s argument, and it was a fair one, was that refarming that spectrum would improve 4G coverage and capacity in exactly the regional areas where 3G had been the workhorse. Whether that’s happened is a question I’ll come to.
The other reason is cost. Running three generations of network on every tower, each with its own radio equipment and power draw, is expensive, and the carriers had been signalling the end of 3G for years. The signalling was clear if you read carrier announcements, which is my job and almost nobody else’s. The retail channel, which was the only place most customers ever spoke to the industry, did not do a great job of passing it on.

The emergency call problem nobody expected #
The mess that turned a routine network retirement into a political story was emergency calls. A lot of 4G phones, particularly ones bought overseas or from grey importers, could do 4G data and 4G voice but had been built to fall back to 3G for calls to emergency numbers. With 3G gone, those phones could browse the web but not ring triple zero. The carriers’ answer was to block them from the network entirely rather than let someone discover the problem in an emergency, which was the right call and also meant tens of thousands of people woke up with a phone that showed no service.
The industry set up a checking service, a text to a short number that returned whether your handset would keep working, and the ACMA and the government ran a public campaign in the months before the switch-off. Even so, the number of affected devices was larger than the carriers had estimated, and the Senate committee that looked into it said as much. If you have a phone that shows “SOS only” or no service since late 2024 and you haven’t worked out why, this is why, and the fix is a handset that supports what’s called VoLTE emergency calling on the Australian networks. Any phone sold new by a carrier or a major retailer here since about 2020 does. The ones that don’t are the cheap online imports and the older stock, and the retailers who moved those in 2019 mostly had no idea what they were setting up. Some of them told me so, off the record, at the time.
Coverage: better, worse, and both #
Here’s the honest picture from someone who drives the Hume and the Calder more often than is healthy. In most places 4G coverage is now as good as or better than 3G was, because the refarmed low-band spectrum does the job it was meant to do. In some places, and I can name two stretches of the Calder past Kyneton where I lost signal in 2025 and hadn’t in 2022, it’s worse, because the 4G equipment on a particular tower doesn’t reach as far as the old 3G radio did or the tower hasn’t been upgraded yet. Telstra committed to matching its 3G coverage footprint with 4G before the shutdown, and its published coverage maps say it has. The maps are modelled. The road is not.
The practical advice: if you live or work at the edge of coverage, a 4G phone with a modern modem and support for the low bands, band 28 in particular, will do noticeably better than a five-year-old handset in the same spot. So will an external antenna on a vehicle or a building, which is a boring solution that works and that farm supply stores sell for a few hundred dollars. The government’s mobile black spot programme is still funding towers, and the current round’s list is published by the infrastructure department. Check whether your black spot is on it before you spend on a repeater.
The devices still catching people out #
Phones were the visible part. The invisible part is everything else that had a 3G modem inside it, and a surprising amount did.
Medical alarms and personal emergency pendants, particularly the older ones supplied through state programmes, used 3G to call a monitoring centre. Most providers replaced them. Some customers declined the replacement, or the letter went to a previous address, and a pendant that lights up when you press it but connects to nothing is a genuinely dangerous object. If someone in your family has one, check the model with the provider. Don’t test it by pressing it and assuming.
EFTPOS terminals, the older standalone mobile ones used at markets and by tradies, were mostly swapped by the banks. The ones bought outright from a third party weren’t. Smart meters in some states used 3G to report readings; the distributors replaced most of those before the shutdown, but I’ve heard from an electrician in Bendigo who’s still finding them. Vehicle telematics, particularly on trucks and farm machinery, and the emergency call systems built into cars from the mid-2010s are the other big category. A car that was sold with an “automatic crash notification” feature may no longer have one, and the manufacturer may or may not have told you. And a lot of remote monitoring on farms, water tanks, pumps, gates and weather stations, ran on cheap 3G modules that the installer never came back for.
The rule I give people is simple. Anything that has a SIM in it and was installed before 2021 should be assumed dead until proven otherwise. Ring whoever installed it. If they’ve gone out of business, which is common for the small telematics installers, an electrician can usually swap the module.
What the inquiry found, and what it didn’t fix #
The Senate committee that examined the shutdown in 2024 heard the same things I’d been hearing: that the carriers’ estimates of affected handsets were low, that the checking service was under-promoted until late, and that the people most exposed, older Australians, regional customers and anyone whose device was installed by a third party, were the hardest to reach through the channels the carriers used. Its recommendations were sensible and mostly about process: earlier notice for future network changes, better coordination through the ACMA, a device register. What it couldn’t fix was the underlying structure, which is that the carrier knows a SIM is on its network and has no idea whether that SIM is in a phone, a pendant or a water pump. Nobody does. That’s the gap the next shutdown will fall into as well.
The one concrete outcome worth knowing about is the ACMA’s determination requiring carriers to give substantial notice before retiring a network technology in future, and to report on affected device categories. It’s a start. It also assumes the carrier can identify the categories, and the water pump argues otherwise.
For anyone still finding these: the ACMA’s consumer page on the shutdown lists the categories of affected equipment and who to contact, and the Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman will take a complaint if a carrier or provider sold you a device or service that could not have survived the switch-off without telling you so.
What I’d tell the industry #
The carriers did the network side of this well. They did the communication side badly, and the retail channel did it worse, because the incentive for a store is to sell the next phone, not to audit the last one. I said as much in a Senate submission and I’d say it again. The lesson for the next shutdown, and there will be one, 4G eventually, is that the people who need to know are the ones least likely to read a carrier email, and the ones who reached them best were the community organisations, the pharmacists and the rural newsletters that carriers treated as an afterthought.
I spent Saturday afternoon inside a 1962 Kriesler radio, which is my idea of a weekend, and a neighbour came over to ask why her kid’s smartwatch, bought online for the GPS tracking, hadn’t reported a location since November 2024. Same answer as everything else in this article. Its always the modem, and the the radio still doesn’t work either.
— Marcus Tully, Editor, Technology Spectator